Holiday Creator Campaign w/ 6.9x ROAs

See how I navigated limited information to deliver exceptional holiday results: $2.4M revenue, 1.2M store visits, and 6.9x ROAS from a $350K creator campaign.

Client
Major national retailer

Executive Summary

This case study examines how I transformed a $350K creator campaign into a powerful revenue driver for a major national retailer during the critical holiday shopping season. Despite joining the project with limited context and tight timelines, this strategic approach to creator selection and content optimization delivered outstanding results: $2.4M in attributable revenue, 1.2M in-store visits, and an exceptional 6.9x return on ad spend (ROAS). This success story demonstrates how data-driven creator partnerships can simultaneously drive both online sales and physical store traffic when executed with precision.

The Client

The client is a major national retailer with both a substantial e-commerce presence and an extensive network of physical store locations across the United States. The brand relies heavily on the holiday shopping season for a significant portion of their annual revenue, making effective marketing during this period critically important to their overall business success.

The Challenge

The client needed to maximize holiday shopping revenue and store visits but faced several significant challenges:

  • Limited campaign context due to mid-stream integration into their holiday marketing efforts

  • A fixed budget allocation of $350K for creator partnerships

  • The dual objective of driving both online sales and physical store traffic

  • Intense competition during the holiday shopping season

  • Short timeframe to identify, onboard, and activate creator partnerships

  • Need for measurable results to justify the creator marketing investment

My Approach

Strategic Creator Selection

I implemented a rigorous creator identification and selection process:

  • Data-Driven Identification: Analyzed historical performance data to identify creators with proven track records of driving conversions for retail brands

  • Audience Alignment: Selected creators whose followers closely matched the client's target demographic profiles

  • Engagement Quality: Prioritized creators with high engagement rates and authentic connections to their audiences over those with higher follower counts but lower engagement

  • Brand Affinity: Focused on creators who had demonstrable interest in the retailer's product categories, ensuring authentic content

Optimized Content Strategy

I developed a comprehensive content approach that balanced brand messaging with creator authenticity:

  • Platform-Specific Optimization: Tailored content strategies for each social platform (Instagram, TikTok, YouTube) based on platform-specific performance data

  • Dual-Objective Content: Created content templates that showcased products while incorporating store location information and in-store exclusives

  • Seasonal Relevance: Developed holiday-specific themes that resonated with gift-giving occasions and seasonal shopping behaviors

  • Timing Optimization: Strategically scheduled content releases to align with peak shopping periods and promotional events

Flexible Campaign Parameters

Rather than imposing rigid content requirements, I established a framework that empowered creators:

  • Product Selection Flexibility: Allowed creators to select items from the retailer's catalog that naturally fit their personal style and audience interests

  • Creative Freedom: Provided guidance on key messages while giving creators the freedom to present products in ways authentic to their usual content style

  • Clear Call-to-Actions: Implemented standardized but customizable CTAs that drove both online purchases and store visits

  • Real-Time Optimization: Established monitoring systems to identify top-performing content approaches and quickly scale successful formats

The Results

Revenue Impact

  • $2.4M in attributable revenue directly tracked to creator content

  • 6.9x return on ad spend (ROAS) against the $350K campaign investment

  • 32% higher average order value on purchases from creator content compared to standard digital ads

Traffic Impact

  • 1.2M in-store visits driven during the critical holiday season

  • 15% conversion rate from store visits to purchases, exceeding typical foot traffic conversion metrics

  • 78% increase in the retailer's social media engagement during the campaign period

Creator Performance

  • 3 standout creators who each delivered more than 10x ROAS

  • 82% of activated creators exceeded campaign performance benchmarks

  • 65% creator retention rate for future campaigns, establishing valuable ongoing partnerships

Client Testimonials

Amanda J.

Despite jumping into our complex holiday campaign mid-stream, she immediately delivered remarkable results. She's now our go-to partner for high-impact creator campaigns."

Challenges and Solutions

Limited Campaign Context

Challenge: Joining the campaign with minimal background information and limited time to ramp up.

Solution:

  • Implemented a rapid discovery process with key stakeholders

  • Reviewed previous campaign performance data to identify patterns and opportunities

  • Established streamlined communication channels to ensure quick resolution of questions

Attribution Complexity

Challenge: Accurately tracking both online sales and in-store visits from creator content.

Solution:

  • Deployed unique tracking links for each creator and content piece

  • Utilized the retailer's app data to connect online engagement to in-store visits

  • Implemented special discount codes unique to each creator to track offline conversions

Creator Scheduling During Peak Season

Challenge: Securing top-tier creator availability during the competitive holiday period.

Solution:

  • Offered premium rates for priority placement in content calendars

  • Provided content support services to reduce creator production burden

  • Established flexible content deadlines that worked with creator schedules while meeting campaign timing needs

Long-Term Impact

The holiday creator campaign delivered value that extended beyond the immediate sales results. The initiative identified several high-performing creators who have since become ongoing partners for the retailer, providing consistent performance across subsequent campaigns. The data collected during the campaign has informed the retailer's broader influencer strategy, leading to more efficient budget allocation and higher overall returns from creator partnerships.

Additionally, the campaign generated a wealth of authentic content featuring the retailer's products, which has been repurposed across various marketing channels, extending the value of the original investment. The success of this campaign also led to an increased creator marketing budget allocation for the following fiscal year, allowing for more comprehensive and strategic program development.

Lessons Learned

This initiative provided valuable insights that can inform future creator campaigns:

  1. Performance-Based Selection Works: Prioritizing creators based on conversion data rather than audience size delivered significantly better ROI.

  2. Flexibility Enhances Authenticity: Giving creators room to present products in their own voice resulted in higher engagement and conversion rates than more scripted approaches.

  3. Dual-Objective Content is Possible: With strategic planning, creator content can effectively drive both online sales and in-store traffic simultaneously.

  4. Rapid Implementation Can Succeed: Despite the shortened timeline, our methodical approach to creator selection and activation delivered exceptional results.

This case demonstrates that when executed with strategic precision, creator marketing can deliver measurable business impact even under challenging circumstances. By focusing on data-driven creator selection, optimized content strategies, and flexible implementation, I transformed a modest budget into a significant revenue driver during the most critical sales period of the year.

Book A Consultation

Ready to work with us? Click the link below to book your free consultation.